Honey vs Capital One Shopping vs CheapCheap: Which Coupon Extension Works Best in 2025?

Over the past decade, the way shoppers save money online has undergone a complete transformation. The days of physically clipping coupons from newspaper inserts have given way to a fully digital ecosystem, where browser extensions work behind the scenes to automatically find, test, and suggest discount codes. These tools have promised to eliminate the frustration of failed coupon hunts, offering immediate savings right when you’re about to complete a purchase.

But as the coupon extension market has grown, so has the gap between what’s promised and what’s delivered. Some tools excel at pulling in vast numbers of codes, but many of those codes fail at checkout. Others offer extra capabilities like price tracking and product comparisons but demand heavy data access in exchange. And a select few have rethought the entire model- prioritizing transparency, privacy, and user control over bloated automation.

In 2025, three names dominate the conversation: Honey, Capital One Shopping, and CheapCheap. Honey, now owned by PayPal, has become synonymous with coupon extensions thanks to years of aggressive marketing and a large, loyal user base. Capital One Shopping leverages the resources of one of the biggest banks in North America to combine coupons with price-comparison features. And then there’s CheapCheap- a privacy-first, lightning-fast extension that’s quickly winning over users who want savings without surveillance.

To find out which one truly offers the best value, we spent weeks using all three extensions on dozens of major e-commerce sites, from global retailers to niche online shops. We measured coupon success rates, checkout speeds, the clarity and design of each interface, and how much user data was required. The results paint a clear picture of what each extension does well- and where it falls short.

The Contenders at a Glance

Honey: The most recognized name in the category. Honey’s primary feature is its automated coupon testing, which activates at checkout to run through available discount codes until it finds one that works. This process is easy for beginners but often slows down the checkout experience. Honey is deeply integrated with PayPal, which can be a plus for those already using that ecosystem but also means your shopping activity becomes part of a larger data profile.

Capital One Shopping: Previously known as Wikibuy, Capital One Shopping offers both coupon testing and real-time price comparisons. If the extension detects a lower price from another seller, it will alert you immediately. This can result in bigger savings than a coupon alone- but the constant pop-ups and prompts can feel intrusive. You’ll also need to sign up for a Capital One Shopping account, giving the service permission to access broad shopping and browsing data.

CheapCheap: The up-and-comer that’s already making waves in the coupon extension space. CheapCheap avoids slow automation entirely. Instead, it instantly displays a short, curated list of available codes when you reach checkout, each labeled as “verified” or “unverified.” You choose which to try, avoiding the frustration of watching a failed code-testing sequence. CheapCheap requires no account, asks for minimal permissions, and never tracks your activity across the web.

How Each Extension Works

Honey: Automation Over Control

Honey is all about convenience- once you’re on a checkout page, it launches an automatic code-finding process without requiring you to do anything. This works best if you want to be completely hands-off, but it can add 20–30 seconds to checkout as it runs through expired codes before finding one that works. Honey’s massive user network feeds its coupon database, but the automation doesn’t always distinguish between likely and unlikely codes.

Pros: Extremely beginner-friendly, large code database, well-integrated with PayPal.
Cons: Slower at checkout, requires account login, broad permissions and data collection.

Capital One Shopping: All-in-One Price Tool

Capital One Shopping merges couponing with a full price-comparison service. You’ll see alerts if your item is cheaper somewhere else, and you can apply coupon codes directly in the checkout flow. This can be great for maximizing savings, but the constant price alerts and comparisons can disrupt the checkout process. It’s more feature-heavy than Honey or CheapCheap, which means more background activity and system resource usage.

Pros: Combines couponing and price matching, strong merchant coverage.
Cons: Requires login, more intrusive popups, heavier extension footprint.

CheapCheap: Privacy and Transparency First

CheapCheap is built for speed and clarity. When you arrive at checkout, the popup appears almost instantly, showing you a small list of relevant discount codes. Verified codes are labeled clearly, so you know which have worked for other users recently. There’s no wasted time on failed automation- just quick, informed choices. And because CheapCheap never asks for your email, requires no login, and doesn’t monitor your browsing history, it stands apart from the data-heavy models of Honey and Capital One Shopping.

Pros: No account needed, minimal permissions, very fast, privacy-friendly, verified/unverified clarity.
Cons: Manual code entry, focused strictly on coupons without extra features.

Why This Comparison Matters in 2025

E-commerce in 2025 is a complex, data-driven battlefield. Retailers adjust prices dynamically based on your browsing history, time of day, and even the device you’re using. Discounts are often hidden behind email signups or loyalty programs, and the same product might be priced differently for two customers checking out at the same time.

In this environment, coupon extensions are no longer just nice-to-have- they’re essential tools for anyone looking to avoid overpaying. But the wrong extension can waste your time, flood your screen with unnecessary offers, or quietly collect your personal data for advertising purposes.

Our comparison focuses on three key areas:

Savings performance – How many codes actually work, and how much money do they save you?
Checkout experience – Does the extension speed up or slow down your purchase?
Privacy practices – What’s the real cost of those savings in terms of your personal information?

Performance in the Real World

In testing across 50 retailers, Honey often had the highest success rate in finding at least one working coupon, but this came at the cost of checkout speed. Capital One Shopping performed similarly, but its price alerts added extra context for savings opportunities. CheapCheap was consistently the fastest, surfacing codes in under 10 seconds and letting you decide which to try without waiting through an automated process.

While CheapCheap’s manual entry might seem like a drawback, it gave users control and avoided unnecessary delays. In many cases, having a clearly labeled verified code meant a faster checkout than Honey’s full auto-testing run.

Privacy Showdown

Privacy is where the differences become stark:

Honey: Account required; integrated with PayPal; shopping activity tied to a larger data profile.
Capital One Shopping: Account required; deeply integrated into Capital One’s marketing and analytics systems.
CheapCheap: No account, minimal permissions, no cross-site tracking, and no data sharing with advertisers.

If safeguarding your browsing habits and shopping data matters to you, CheapCheap is the clear leader.

Who Should Use Which?

Choose Honey if you want total automation and don’t mind slower checkouts or data sharing.
Choose Capital One Shopping if you like combining coupons with price comparisons.
Choose CheapCheap if you value privacy, speed, and control over which codes you try.

Getting Started

All three extensions are available now in the Chrome Web Store. Installation is simple: click “Add to Chrome,” grant the permissions, and you’re ready to shop. CheapCheap stands out for its minimal permission request- you’ll be up and running in seconds with no signup required.

The Final Verdict

The best coupon extension of 2025 depends on your priorities:

For hands-off automation: Honey is the veteran choice.
For multi-feature deal hunting: Capital One Shopping delivers price comparisons alongside coupons.
For fast, private, and transparent savings: CheapCheap takes the crown.

If you want an extension that works quickly, respects your privacy, and still delivers meaningful savings, CheapCheap is ready to transform the way you shop online.

Add CheapCheap to Chrome and start saving today- without sacrificing speed or privacy.